Large Schools
| POY | Shaun Dolac | West Seneca East |
| OPOY | Jake Ritts | St. Francis |
| DPOY | Conor Mahony | Lancaster |
| LPOY | Tyler Doty | St. Joe’s |
| STPOY | Joe Jamison | Canisius |
| COY | Jerry Smith | St. Francis |
| QB | Aaron Chase | Starpoint |
| RB | Djae Perry | Bennett |
| RB | John Speyer | West Seneca West |
| RB | Kaiyer Fields | McKinley |
| WR/TE | Malik Brooks | Lockport |
| WR/TE | Dominik Thomas | St. Francis |
| WR/TE | Matt Spina | Starpoint |
| QB/RB/WR | Jordan Parks | Niagara Wheatfield |
| LM | Nick Hamme | West Seneca East |
| LM | Jihad Loynes | Bennett |
| LM | Josh Wilson | West Seneca West |
| LM | Max Anderson | Hutch Tech |
| LM | David Gaca | Lancaster |
| K | Tristian Vandenburg | Canisius |
| DEF | Dylan Kelly | Williamsville North |
| DEF | Jon Stevens | Clarence |
| DEF | Tyler Bailey | Frontier |
| DEF | Mike Glinski | West Seneca West |
| DEF | Liam Scheuer | West Seneca West |
| DEF | Jake DeWolf | Niagara Wheatfield |
| DEF | Robert Giancarlo | Sweet Home |
| DEF | Jayon Renfro | South Park |
| DEF | Elijah Lewis | South Park |
| DEF | Dawson Tyger | St. Francis |
| DEF | Michael Pataky | Orchard Park |
| DE/DL/LB | Reily Wood | St. Joe’s |
| PUNT | Jack Westermeier | Canisius |
Small Schools
| POY | Aaron Wahler | Cleveland Hill |
| OPOY | Cole Snyder | Southwestern |
| DPOY | Mike Rigerman | Pioneer |
| LPOY | Andrew Bernard | Randolph/Frewsburg |
| STPOY | Alex Card | Southwestern |
| COY | Bill Atlas | Wilson |
| QB | Steve Frerichs | Wilson |
| RB | Javon Thomas | Cleveland Hill |
| RB | Rashad Law | Maryvale |
| RB | Joell Colon | Fredonia |
| WR/TE | Jermaine Haynes Jr. | Cardinal O’Hara |
| WR/TE | Cameron Barmore | Clymer/Sherman/Panama |
| WR/TE | Tamell Bass | Cheektowaga |
| QB/RB/WR | Keshone Beal | Cheektowaga |
| LM | Stephen Boyd Jr. | Cardinal O’Hara |
| LM | Joe Powers | Lewiston Porter |
| LM | Lane Patton | Pioneer |
| LM | Austin Domanowski | Cheektowaga |
| LM | Ben Restivo | Albion |
| K | Jake Cianciosa | St. Mary’s |
| DEF | Justin Hemphill | Cardinal O’Hara |
| DEF | Remir Velazquez | Cardinal O’Hara |
| DEF | Chris Diem | Cleveland Hill |
| DEF | Zach Fischer | Chautauqua Lake |
| DEF | Easton Tanner | Maple Grove |
| DEF | Drew Westmorland | Wilson |
| DEF | Finn O’Brien | East Aurora/Holland |
| DEF | Syncier Middlebrooks | Maryvale |
| DEF | Andrew Musacchio | Gowanda |
| DEF | Taivaughn Roach | Cheektowaga |
| DEF | Derek Ecklund | Clymer/Sherman/Panama |
| DE/DL/LB | Robbie Penhollow | Cassadaga Valley/Falconer |
| PUNT | Kyle Gold | St. Mary’s |
