Large Schools
| NAME | SCHOOL | |
| POY | JAKE RITTS | ST FRANCIS |
| OPOY | XZAVIER JANCZYLIK | ST FRANCIS |
| DPOY | CJ OZOLINS | CANISIUS |
| STPOY | JOE CARLSON | STARPOINT |
| LPOY | ERIC SCHON | ST FRANCIS |
| COY | RICH ROBBINS | CANISIUS |
| FIRST TEAM OFFENSE | ||
| QB | JASON MANSELL | LANCASTER |
| QB | JACK SHARP | ORCHARD PARK |
| RB | KEITH JACKSON | SOUTH PARK |
| RB | D’JAE PERRY | BENNETT |
| RB | ISAIAH SIMMONS | WEST SENECA WEST |
| WR | SAM KLINE | ST JOES |
| WR | ANTONIO CORSI | ST FRANCIS |
| WR | SHAWN DAVIS | LANCASTER |
| K | THOMAS HOLLANDER | ORCHARD PARK |
| OL | MATT BAKSA | ORCHARD PARK |
| OL | JASON WALKER | ST JOES |
| OL | DONOVAN CORNELIUS | CANISIUS |
| OL | RYAN BITKA | AMHERST |
| OL | AJ URBANIAK | WILL SOUTH |
| OL | DYLAN FARNER | SOUTH PARK |
| OL | GENO BRUCE | HAMBURG |
| SECOND TEAM OFFENSE | ||
| QB | TYLER BAKER | CANISIUS |
| QB | ZAC BOYES | KENMORE WEST |
| RB | JOE DIXON | CANISIUS |
| RB | JAMEL LUCAS | SWEET HOME |
| RB | SAVON VANSICKLE | JAMESTOWN |
| WR | HENRY HUNTER | MCKINLEY |
| WR | ANDRE AUGUSTINIAK | SOUTH PARK |
| WR | MICAH BROWN | ST JOES |
| K | MARK ARRIZZA | ST FRANCIS |
| OL | DAVID BARTHOLOMEW | ST FRANCIS |
| OL | MATT WAGNER | ORCHARD PARK |
| OL | DARRICK BURT | MCKINLEY |
| OL | JEREMIAH WILLIAMS | BENNETT |
| OL | JAKE TROUP | CANISIUS |
| OL | JEREMY CUTHBERT | WEST SENECA WEST |
| OL | TIM OSBORN | NORTH TONAWANDA |
| FIRST TEAM DEFENSE | ||
| DEF | MARQWAN FLUITT | SOUTH PARK |
| DEF | BRANDON BROWN | SOUTH PARK |
| DEF | SAM MOSS | MCKINLEY |
| DEF | JUNIOR SVEN | MCKINLEY |
| DEF | CONOR MAHONY | LANCASTER |
| DEF | MATT MARSCHNER | LANCASTER |
| DEF | MICHAEL PATAKY | ORCHARD PARK |
| DEF | MALACHI CHARLESTON | CANISIUS |
| DEF | JAMES CARRINGTON | ST. JOE’S |
| DEF | JACOB SHUL | ORCHARD PARK |
| DEF | JAYLEN BUTERA | JAMESTOWN |
| DEF | RYAN CULHANE | CLARENCE |
| SECOND TEAM DEFENSE | ||
| DEF | MATT JAWORSKI | ST FRANCIS |
| DEF | ANTHONY MACK | SOUTH PARK |
| DEF | JAYSEAN ARMSTEAD | SOUTH PARK |
| DEF | DEVON COTTOM | MCKINLEY |
| DEF | TAKEO FUNDERBURK | MCKINLEY |
| DEF | AVION BELL | MCKINLEY |
| DEF | RASHAD PERRY | BENNETT |
| DEF | JOSH JELONEK | LANCASTER |
| DEF | JAKE DEAN | STARPOINT |
| DEF | IVORY PARKER | HUTCH TECH |
| DEF | TYRELL LAWS | SWEET HOME |
| DEF | TYLER PIRRITANO | ORCHARD PARK |
Small Schools
| NAME | SCHOOL | |
| POY | CAM BARMORE | CSP |
| OPOY | TYWON WRIGHT | SOUTHWESTERN |
| DPOY | TERYON VERNON | MARITIME |
| STPOY | ADDISON COPELAND | MARITIME |
| LPOY | COOPER PANNES | SOUTHWESTERN |
| COY | TY HARPER/JOE LICATA | CSP/TIMON |
| FIRST TEAM OFFENSE | ||
| QB | AIDAN KENNEDY | SOUTHWESTERN |
| QB | GERRIT HINSDALE | CSP |
| RB | JAYDEN LASSITER | PORTVILLE |
| RB | TRA’E HILL | PIONEER |
| RB | GINO FONTANAROSA | LEWISTON PORTER |
| WR | DOM CERTO | SOUTHWESTERN |
| WR | TYLER ROBINSON | EDEN |
| WR | TYLER BARRY | IROQUOIS |
| K | THOMAS FURMANSKI | ALBION |
| OL | SAM TORRIE | CARDINAL O’HARA |
| OL | MASON FRITZKE | TONAWANDA |
| OL | CODY WILSON | ALBION |
| OL | AARON DOYLE | PIONEER |
| OL | LUCAS RATER | CSP |
| OL | TAMARIO BASS | CHEEKTOWAGA |
| OL | SAM MEST | OLEAN |
| FIRST TEAM DEFENSE | ||
| DEF | MEKHI BRIDGERS | MARITIME |
| DEF | JAKE SKINNER | FREDONIA |
| DEF | JARED MONTGOMERY | EAST AURORA |
| DEF | DOMINIC BROWN | MARYVALE |
| DEF | JASON FRAZER | TONAWANDA |
| DEF | JORDAN KING | PIONEER |
| DEF | DECLAN FAERY | WILSON |
| DEF | CONRAD THOMAS | SOUTHWESTERN |
| DEF | CHRIS DIEM | CLEVELAND HILL |
| DEF | JADEN HEERS | NEWFANE |
| DEF | JOHN SWABIK | CSP |
| DEF | AIDAN SMITH | AKRON |
| SECOND TEAM OFFENSE | ||
| QB | TREY KLEITZ | IROQUOIS |
| QB | ROBERT ATLAS | WILSON |
| RB | RYAN JAFARIJAN | CHAUTAUQUA LAKE/BROCTON |
| RB | BLAKE NOLAN | IROQUOIS |
| RB | MAURICE VAUGHN | MARITIME |
| WR | JACOREY HAYNES | CHEEKTOWAGA |
| WR | ZAVON OVERTON | CSP |
| WR | KEVIN HILLMAN | ALBION |
| K | THOMAS BAIA | WILSON |
| OL | JULIAN MORALES | PORTVILLE |
| OL | NICK LAROCK | NEWFANE |
| OL | KYLE TRIM | MAPLE GROVE |
| OL | NICK PUTCHER | CHAUTAUQUA LAKE/BROCTON |
| OL | LUKE MCMAHON | BISHOP TIMON |
| OL | BEN PLONKA | IROQUOIS |
| OL | LOGAN LEEDS | AKRON |
| SECOND TEAM DEFENSE | ||
| DEF | ANDREW CORSER | ROY-HART |
| DEF | MARK MILLMAN | DUNKIRK |
| DEF | MICHAEL BUTSCH | TONAWANDA |
| DEF | DENTON TILLY | PIONEER |
| DEF | ZACK WOLFER | FRANKLINVILLE/ELLICOTTVILLE |
| DEF | NIKLAS LOGEL | FRANKLINVILLE/ELLICOTTVILLE |
| DEF | ALEX REINHARDT | BISHOP TIMON |
| DEF | CONNOR COOPER | CSP |
| DEF | JONATHAN STANISZEWSKI | EAST AURORA |
| DEF | BEN MAHAR | WILSON |
| DEF | NICK PANTUSO | OLEAN |
| DEF | COLLIN MOWER | CASSADAGA VALLEY/FALCONER |
